Paper or Plastic?
You probably did not realize how difficult that question really is!
Many Americans go with plastic, either by habit or because they believe the environmental impact of plastic bags is less than that of paper.  No one wants to cut down trees just to make a bag for your groceries, right?  But is paper worse than plastic?
Paper bags produce 70% more air pollution and 50 times more water pollution than plastic bag production. Yet, plastic bags have their own problems:  80% of all litter on roadsides, parks and beaches is plastic.  In some countries like Bangladesh and India, plastic garbage bags clog drainage systems so much that they cause massive flooding damage.  And think about this:  every square mile of the ocean has about 46,000 pieces of floating non biodegradable plastic in it, most of it plastic bags.
What’s the Verdict?
Read on (www.greennurture.com) to see what others are thinking and doing about this dilemma!
Then login now to GreenNurture.com and spend just 2 seconds giving us and everyone else your 2 cents’ worth.
And while you are at it, see what everyone else is saying!
Do you have a favorite quote, statistic, question or idea about sustainability?  Share it with us and we will post the best of them in our weekly email!  Contact GreenNurture’s Chief Satisfaction Officer, Sally Russell, at sally@greennurture.com.Plastic bag litter

In the U.S., four out of five grocery bags are plastic, with the average American family accumulating nearly 60 plastic bags for every four trips to the grocery store.  But is this by choice?  If Americans knew how damaging those plastic bags are to the environment, would they choose them?  Consider this (http://www.reuseit.com/learn-more/top-facts/plastic-bag-facts):

500 billion to 1 trillion plastic bags are used every year, worldwide.    Plastic bag

About 1 million plastic bags are used every minute.

A single plastic bag can take up to 1,000 years to degrade

The U.S. alone goes through 100 billion single-use plastic bags. This costs retailers about $4 billion a year

Plastic bags are the second-most common type of ocean refuse, after cigarette butts, with every single square mile of ocean having about 46,000 pieces of floating plastic in it.  70% of which finds its way to the ocean floor, where it will likely never degrade

Plastic bags remain toxic even after they break down.

Only between .5% to 3% of all bags winds up recycled

So Choose Paper, Right?

Not so fast, pardner!  There is evidence that the ready alternative, paper bags, are also very damaging to the environment:

Paper bag production produces 70% more air pollution and 50 times more water pollution than plastic bag production

Waste by weight of paper bags is 400% higher than plastic and the amount of waste by volume is higher by more than 250%. With landfills running low on space, plastic is obviously preferable to plastic

Cutting down forests to make paper bags is environmentally costly, as is transporting the bags to their ultimate destinations. Plastic bags are much thinner and lighter than paper bags, and take about 1/45 the truck space that paper bags take.   That means transporting paper bags consumes 45 times more fuel, and produces 45 times the congestion and smog of plastic bags.  (http://www.plasticbageconomics.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=30&Itemid=45)

What’s the Answer: Think Outside the Bag

The first plastic sandwich bag came on the market in 1957.  It took 20 more years before grocers began asking, “Paper or Plastic?”  In its relatively brief lifespan, plastic has made a widespread, indelible impact on the planet.

Because they are such an environmental problem and eyesore, countries such as Ireland, Taiwan, South Africa, Australia and Bangladesh have taxed the bags heavily, or outright banned them.  Several cities in the U.S. and the U.K. are doing the same.

Instead of paper or plastic, many people are now using reusable bags made from string, recycled plastic, baskets and boxes.

If you do choose plastic, please recycle them.  Retailers like Wal-Mart and Target have recycling centers at many of their stores where you can drop off your used plastic bags.  Between April and December, 2010, Target collected more than 170 million shopping bags (equal to more than 1800 tons). Laid end-to-end, they would stretch from L.A. to NYC more than 17 times.

So, the next time you are asked, “Paper or Plastic?” will you be able to say “Neither, I brought my own”?

Back To Top